Holden M. Rasmussen (Newcastle University)




Another Body, Another Fantasy: From Perversions through Fantasy to Psychosexuality


In a 1967 article for Cahiers pour l’analyse, Jacques Nassif shifts the focus of Freud’s ‘A Child is Being Beaten’ from the aetiology of perversions to the question of fantasy. Nassif concludes that there is a fundamental fantasy on display in these cases and conducts an 'archaeology’ of this fundamental fantasy, locating the origin of fantasy with the origin of sexual difference: castration and the Oedipus complex. This indicates that fundamental fantasy is grafted onto a preexisting structure, and castration and sexual difference alone do not foment fantasy. In the final lines of the article, Nassif wonders if another fantasy, corresponding to a different body and verbalization, could be built on this structure, but admits his reading does not permit an answer to this question. I propose that a reading that shifts the focus in the text again provides an affirmative answer to Nassif’s question and some indications of an elaboration. In my reading, without abandoning Nassif, psychosexuality is the conceptual focus. Psychosexuality, as Freud elsewhere formulates it, is not the fact of sex, sexual difference, or sexuality but a problem and an object that defines a different ground and set of limits for psychoanalytic investigation. In the context of the fantasy in ‘A Child is Being Beaten’, Nassif’s opening leads me to speculate that, indeed, bodies, verbalizations, and fantasies of another type can form. The question is: are these bodies beyond Oedipus? Are these so-called queer bodies? Avant la lettre, Nassif’s text traces another path traversing a recurrent, contentious question for psychoanalysis and philosophy today.